Skip to content

IMMORTALITY vs Her Story

See how two games stack up across what matters most to you.

Side-by-side Comparison

IMMORTALITYHer Story
Weight
importance
Story & NarrativeDepth, writing, characters98
CombatMechanics, feel, challenge11
ExplorationFreedom, secrets, rewards76
Co-op ExperienceMultiplayer, teamwork11
DifficultyChallenge, learning curve54
World DesignImmersion, atmosphere86
Build / Playstyle VarietyCustomization, options11
Session LengthHow long typical sessions are45-120 minone evening

Short answer

Both are Sam Barlow archive mysteries, but they differ in scale and focus. Her Story is a tight, intimate puzzle built around one actress's performance and a single searchable database; you can finish it in a night. IMMORTALITY expands into three full fake films with match-cut navigation, nonlinear exploration, and a darker, stranger mystery. Choose Her Story for a perfect short story; choose IMMORTALITY for a deeper, more daunting dive.

A Short Story vs. a Labyrinthine Novel

Sam Barlow's two archive-scrubbing mysteries ask you to piece together truth from fragmented footage, but they feel like different literary forms. Her Story is a perfectly shaped short story: one desk, one database, one face. You type queries, watch interview clips, and let the story assemble itself in your mind.

It's intimate, immediate, and finishable in a single evening, with real ambiguity that lingers because you never escape the frame of that single interrogation room. IMMORTALITY, in contrast, is a labyrinthine novel. Three fully shot fake films—each with its own cast, sets, and plot—wait to be excavated.

Navigation is nonlinear, powered by match-cut transitions that let you hop between reels by following movement or a gaze. There are no goals handed to you; insight is the only guide. The revelation is darker, stranger, and wrapped in film-history occult vertigo. Where Her Story offers one unforgettable performance in infinite assembly orders, IMMORTALITY drops you into an entire film archive and asks you to find the thread that ties it together—or to lose yourself trying.

Choose Her Story for the Purity of the Search Box

If you want the cleanest, most focused iteration of the archive-mystery idea, Her Story is the place to start. The entire world is a single database and a single face—Marissa Marcel's? No, the actress in the interview clips, whose performance carries the whole weight of the narrative. The search box is your only map; every query you type sends you down a different corridor, and the story reorders itself based on what you choose to look for.

That purity is a strength: there's no other system to learn, no spatial navigation, just the raw pleasure of matching words to footage. The experience is compact, yet it never feels small. The ambiguity is genuine, because you always know there are clips you haven't seen, threads you haven't pulled, and the film grain and CRT glare make every frame feel like evidence. It is an evening-length commitment that rewards attention, and the payoff is a story that stays with you long after the screen goes black.

For players who want a complete, self-contained mystery—one with a single, unforgettable face and a search-driven loop that feels like a perfect haiku—Her Story is the sharper choice.

Choose IMMORTALITY to Lose Yourself in Three Films

If you'd rather dive headfirst into a deep, sprawling enigma, IMMORTALITY is your labyrinth. Here, the archive is three complete films, each shot in a different style and era, and the act of scrubbing through them is a kind of cinema detective work. Match-cut navigation is the magic: click on a matching pose, a similar object, or an echo of a gesture, and the scene jumps to another moment across the films.

It's a non-linear exploration that feels like free-association, letting you build connections without being told where to look. The trade-off is that no goals are given. You must supply the insight. The mystery is darker and stranger, steeped in occult undertones and film-history vertigo, and it rewards patience and a willingness to sit with discomfort. This is not an evening's 'short story'; it's a novel you have to assemble from three separate volumes.

If you want a pure discovery experience, where every match-cut reveals another hidden seam and the world feels vast and haunted, IMMORTALITY is the deeper cut. Bring a notebook, embrace the nonlinearity, and let the films take over.

Key facts, side by side

IMMORTALITYHer Story
Release date2022-08-302015-06-24
PublisherHalf MermaidSam Barlow
Price (USD)$11.99 (40% off)captured 2026-08-15$9.99captured 2026-08-14
Main-story length~6.4 hrs (collected estimate)~2.4 hrs (collected estimate)
Steam player reviews83.6% positive (1,975 reviews)captured 2026-08-1589.4% positive (10,385 reviews)captured 2026-08-14
Critic score (Metacritic)87/100 (48 critic reviews)86/100 (52 critic reviews)
Difficulty4.4/10 (moderate)3.3/10 (easy)

Main-story figures are collected playtime estimates (captured 2026-08-16), not exact completion times.

Similar Games to Consider

Based on what you like in both games

Related comparisons